Patty Melt on Dark Rye
Patty Melt on Dark Rye
This is my second patty melt post. The first I used Gina and Pat Neely’s recipe from their most recent cookbook. Love me some Gina. I remember liking it quite a bit so I thought I would try it again and maybe try a new sauce. Not sure where patty melts came from and why they are not called a hamburger but “real” diner patty melts must have four things; beef patty, rye bread, swiss cheese and caramelized onions.
For my burgers, I can really go any direction on sauces…mayo, mustard or ketchup. Probably Mayo and mustard edge out ketchup. So I wanted to make the typical secret sauces that are basically thousand island dressing. I backed off ketchup and added a few non-traditional ingredients for some tang and zip. It turned out okay probably not as good as the Neely version. I went with dark rye and in the future switch back to the lighter rye.
3/4 lbs Grass Fed Ground beef (85-90%)
4 tsp of Dukes Mayo
1 tsp of Worcestershire Sauce
Season Salt and Pepper
1 Red onion
2 tbs of Dukes Mayo
1 tbs Stone Ground Mustard
1 tbs Ketchup
splash of soy
splash of Tabasco
splash of Sriracha
3 spoons of Wickles Pickles relish (2 for you and 1 for the sauce)
1. The onions will take 20 minutes to caramelize so start by cutting the onion in strips. In a medium non stick pan on medium heat with a splash of oil, cook these for 20 minutes until dark and sweet like below. One tip is to continue to add a little water to keep them from burning. Just splash it every 3 minutes.
2. Mix up your sauce. You can use whatever floats your boat. I was just screwing around and whipped this one up. Basically Thousand Island or everyone’s secret sauce. The Soy, Tabasco and Sriracha are the outliers. Mix and put into fridge.
3. Form your patties into the shape of your bread and make it a little bigger to allow for shrinkage. To the beef I seasoned with “season salt”, black pepper and about 2 tsp of Ketchup and a splash of Worcestershire.
4. Let’s make some patty melts. Your onions are cooked and cooling. You get a large cast iron skillet on medium heat with a splash of oil. Cook your patties to medium rare and pull them out of the pan and let them rest with the onions.
5. Wipe that pan and put it back on the fire. Lower the temp to medium low. Now I learned this tip from Bon Appetit. Instead of buttering your bread you spread about a 1 tsp of Dukes Mayo on the outside (grill side down). Build your melt in the pan by adding the bread, swiss, patty, onions, cheddar and then spread your sauce on the bread and top it.